Dogs are often referred to as “man’s best friend” for a reason. Their ability to bond with humans is undeniable, and one of the ways they demonstrate this bond is through emotional contagion—the phenomenon where they “catch” emotions from both other dogs and humans. Emotional contagion is considered the most basic form of empathy, allowing dogs to feel and respond to the emotions around them. This trait makes dogs exceptional companions, capable of providing comfort when we need it most. At A Peaceful Pack, we recognize the emotional depth of dogs, and our training methods focus on understanding and nurturing these emotional connections between dogs and their owners.
In this blog post, we will explore the science behind emotional contagion in dogs, how it demonstrates empathy, and how this connection impacts both dog behavior and human-dog relationships. We will also discuss how you can recognize and respond to your dog’s emotional sensitivity, helping to create a deeper bond with your furry friend.
What is Emotional Contagion?
Emotional contagion refers to the ability to "catch" and reflect the emotions of others. This is not limited to humans—dogs are also capable of emotional contagion, meaning they can sense and feel emotions that others around them are experiencing. For example, if a person is feeling anxious or stressed, their dog might also begin to show signs of anxiety, such as pacing, whining, or displaying other stress-related behaviors.
A study conducted by Joly-Mascheroni et al. (2008) highlighted the connection between dogs and humans through emotional contagion by demonstrating that dogs can yawn contagiously in response to human yawns. The study found that dogs, like humans, are more likely to yawn when they see a familiar person yawning. This simple act suggests a level of empathy in dogs that goes beyond mere observation; it shows that dogs are emotionally attuned to their human companions.
The Science Behind Dogs and Emotional Contagion
The phenomenon of emotional contagion in dogs has been the subject of various scientific studies, and the evidence shows that dogs have a strong ability to mirror the emotional states of both humans and other dogs. For example, researchers have found that dogs exhibit signs of empathic concern—a behavior akin to empathy in humans—when they notice their owner or another dog in distress.
One of the most compelling examples of emotional contagion is the contagious yawn. As mentioned earlier, dogs will often yawn in response to human yawns, but this behavior is not random. It indicates that the dog is emotionally connected to the person and is responding in a way that mirrors human empathy. According to a study by Romero et al. (2013), dogs are more likely to yawn in response to their owner's yawns than to the yawns of strangers, showing that this emotional connection is stronger with those they are bonded to.
In addition to yawning, dogs have also been shown to exhibit consolatory behaviors, such as approaching and licking their owner when they are crying or upset. This type of behavior is a clear indicator that dogs can recognize emotional distress in humans and attempt to provide comfort, much like humans do for one another.
How Emotional Contagion Affects Dog Behavior
Dogs that are highly empathetic and susceptible to emotional contagion may react in various ways to the emotions of their human companions. This emotional sensitivity can have both positive and negative effects on a dog's behavior.
1. Positive Effects of Emotional Contagion
Providing Comfort: One of the most heartwarming aspects of emotional contagion is when dogs respond to their owners’ emotions in comforting ways. If you're feeling sad or stressed, your dog may cuddle up to you, place their head on your lap, or follow you around more closely. At A Peaceful Pack, we often see this in the way dogs bond with their humans. Their ability to sense emotional shifts can strengthen the human-animal connection, making them wonderful companions during tough times.
Enhanced Training Success: Emotionally connected dogs may also be more attuned to their owner’s moods and cues during training. When you’re calm and patient, your dog can sense this, which helps them stay relaxed and focused on learning. Positive reinforcement training, which is central to A Peaceful Pack’s methodology, works exceptionally well with dogs that are emotionally connected to their owners. These dogs often thrive on the praise and positive emotions they feel from their owners during training sessions.
2. Challenges of Emotional Contagion
Absorbing Negative Emotions: While emotional contagion is largely beneficial, it can also be challenging if you or other members of your household are experiencing stress, anxiety, or frustration. Dogs can absorb these negative emotions, leading to anxiety or reactivity in the dog. For example, if you are anxious about an upcoming vet visit, your dog may pick up on that and become anxious as well, even before arriving at the vet's office.
Reactivity and Fear: In multi-dog households, emotional contagion can spread among the dogs, leading to shared stress or excitement. If one dog becomes anxious or reactive in a specific situation, the other dogs may quickly pick up on that emotion and mirror the behavior. This is why at A Peaceful Pack, we emphasize the importance of calm energy in group settings and dog daycare environments, where dogs are constantly interacting with each other.
Emotional Contagion as a Form of Empathy
The ability to feel what others are feeling is a hallmark of empathy, and emotional contagion in dogs is considered a basic form of empathy. Dogs may not experience complex empathy in the way that humans do, but their ability to recognize and respond to emotional cues in others—whether human or dog—demonstrates a clear empathetic connection.
When a dog sees their owner crying or hears distress in their voice, they may respond by licking their owner’s face, bringing them a toy, or simply staying close. This behavior, which we see often in dogs at A Peaceful Pack, is a sign that the dog recognizes emotional distress and is attempting to comfort their human.
How to Recognize Emotional Contagion in Your Dog
As a dog owner, it's important to be aware of how your emotions may be influencing your dog. Signs that your dog is experiencing emotional contagion include:
Mirroring emotions: Your dog may show signs of happiness, excitement, or stress based on your emotional state. For example, if you’re feeling anxious, your dog may begin pacing, whining, or becoming more clingy.
Contagious yawning: As mentioned earlier, if your dog yawns after you yawn, it may indicate a deep emotional connection between you and your pet (Joly-Mascheroni et al., 2008).
Consolatory behaviors: If your dog responds to your distress by trying to comfort you, such as sitting close, licking you, or whining, it’s a sign they are emotionally attuned to your feelings.
Strengthening Your Emotional Bond with Your Dog
Recognizing emotional contagion in your dog is just the first step. Strengthening your bond with them through understanding and empathy is key. At A Peaceful Pack, we encourage positive reinforcement techniques and calm training methods that help reinforce the emotional connection between you and your dog. When you remain calm and consistent, your dog is more likely to mirror those behaviors, leading to a stronger, more balanced relationship.
By recognizing and nurturing your dog’s empathetic abilities, you can help them feel more secure and emotionally connected to you. This, in turn, leads to a happier, more confident dog.
Conclusion: Emotional Contagion at A Peaceful Pack
Dogs are more than just pets—they’re emotionally intelligent companions capable of experiencing and responding to the feelings of those around them. Emotional contagion, the ability to “catch” emotions, is one of the many ways dogs demonstrate their empathy and deepen their bond with their owners. At A Peaceful Pack, we focus on fostering this emotional connection between dogs and their humans, using it as a foundation for effective training and care.
Whether your dog is comforting you during a tough time or mirroring your excitement during play, their empathetic abilities are one of the many reasons dogs are such valuable companions. If you’re interested in learning more about how A Peaceful Pack can help you strengthen the bond with your dog, contact us today to explore our training and care services.
References:
Joly-Mascheroni, R. M., Senju, A., & Shepherd, A. J. (2008). Dogs catch human yawns. Biology Letters, 4(5), 446-448. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2008.0333
Romero, T., Konno, A., & Hasegawa, T. (2013). Familiarity bias and physiological responses in contagious yawning by dogs support link to empathy. PLOS One, 8(8), e71323. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0071323
Comments